Why the debate around neurodiversity is doing more harm than people realise.
There seems to be an increasing amount of conversation about ADHD and autism being overdiagnosed. Apparently, there are suddenly too many people identifying as neurodivergent, too many people seeking assessments and too many people talking about their experiences.
But I have a question.
Are we really overdiagnosing people, or are we simply becoming better at recognising something that has always existed?
I often think about left-handedness.
There was a time when children were discouraged, and sometimes forced, not to write with their left hand. When attitudes changed and people were allowed to be left-handed, the number of people openly identifying as left-handed increased.
That didn’t mean left-handedness had suddenly become fashionable. It meant people were finally allowed to be themselves.
I wonder whether we’re seeing something similar with autism and ADHD.
We have more knowledge available to us than ever before. Google, social media, TikTok and even AI have given people opportunities to discover and understand things about themselves that previous generations simply didn’t have access to.
Of course, social media isn’t a substitute for a professional assessment. But it can be the beginning of somebody recognising something in themselves that they’ve struggled to understand their entire life.
And why should that be a bad thing?
My Own Diagnosis Changed Everything
I was 30 when I received my autism diagnosis. During that process, ADHD was identified as well.
I cannot overstate how much that changed my perspective on life.
Suddenly, things made sense. Experiences I’d struggled to understand, behaviours I’d questioned and feelings I’d carried for years began to fit together.
It wasn’t about finding an excuse for anything. It was about finally understanding myself.
And that understanding was life-changing.
I’m proud of being neurodivergent. It’s part of who I am, how I think, how I experience the world and how I relate to other people.
But here’s something I find particularly upsetting about the current conversation.
Even I sometimes find myself doubting my own diagnosis when I hear people talking about overdiagnosis.
Despite having been assessed, despite understanding myself and despite the work I’ve done through therapy and self-reflection, these conversations can still make me question myself.
Sometimes they even make me reluctant to tell people I’m neurodivergent.
And I find that incredibly sad.
Neurodivergence Isn’t an Excuse
One of the things that worries me is the assumption that people use ADHD or autism as an excuse for their behaviour.
I think this demonstrates just how little some people understand about what being neurodivergent can actually feel like.
Autism and ADHD can affect so many areas of everyday life. They influence how we process information, manage emotions, experience relationships and navigate the world around us.
For me, there are times when it feels like walking along a very thin tightrope.
One wrong move, one difficult interaction or one unexpected situation can completely change the direction of my day.
Something that another person might brush off can leave me struggling with anxiety, low mood or emotional overwhelm.
Sometimes it can take a considerable amount of time to build myself back up again.
And when you’re already managing those experiences, hearing people publicly question whether people like you are genuinely neurodivergent adds another layer of pressure.
It can make you worry about how others perceive you, whether they’ll believe you or whether they’ll dismiss your experiences as excuses.
That isn’t harmless debate.
Those conversations can have a very real impact on people’s mental health.
Neurodivergence Is Part of Who I Am
I think we also need to be careful about how we talk about autism and ADHD.
For me, being neurodivergent isn’t something separate from my identity. It isn’t something I want to get rid of or something that needs to be fixed.
It’s part of who I am.
Autism and ADHD are neurodevelopmental conditions, not mental illnesses in themselves, although living in a world that doesn’t always accommodate neurodivergent people can contribute to significant mental health difficulties.
And I think that’s an important distinction.
We spend so much time discussing diagnoses, labels and statistics that we sometimes forget we’re talking about human beings.
People who may have spent decades feeling different.
People who have struggled with anxiety, self-esteem or relationships without understanding why.
People who have been told they’re difficult, lazy, oversensitive or simply not trying hard enough.
And people who, through an assessment, may finally begin to understand themselves.
Why would we want to discourage that?
Is This Really About Diagnosis, or Is It About Money?
I can’t help wondering whether some of the political conversation around overdiagnosis is actually driven by concerns about funding.
Assessments cost money. Support services cost money. Providing reasonable adjustments and appropriate resources requires investment.
And when demand increases, there are difficult decisions to be made.
But I worry that instead of having an honest conversation about funding and the need for better services, the discussion risks becoming one about whether people genuinely need support in the first place.
I’m not suggesting that assessment standards shouldn’t be examined. Of course they should. People deserve accurate, thorough and professional assessments.
But questioning the quality of assessment services is very different from creating a culture in which neurodivergent people feel they have to justify their existence.
Sometimes it feels as though the message is simply to stop asking questions, stop seeking support and learn to put up with things.
And I don’t think that’s acceptable.
To Anyone Waiting for an Assessment
If you’re currently waiting for an autism or ADHD assessment and you’re hearing all this conversation about overdiagnosis, I want to say something to you.
Please don’t let the noise put you off.
Continue with the process if it’s something you feel is right for you.
You don’t need to justify your wish to understand yourself.
An assessment might confirm autism or ADHD, or it might help identify another explanation for your experiences. Either way, gaining a better understanding of yourself can be incredibly valuable.
For me, receiving my diagnosis at 30 changed my life.
It helped me make sense of experiences I’d spent years questioning.
And nobody should be made to feel ashamed for wanting that understanding.
Are We Putting Budgets Before People?
I sometimes wonder whether the politicians and commentators driving this debate actually care about the emotional consequences of what they’re saying.
Personally, I don’t think they do.
I think too much of this conversation comes down to budgets, funding and how much money can be saved.
But we’re not just figures on a spreadsheet. We’re human beings, and these conversations have consequences.
When somebody who’s spent years struggling finally begins to understand themselves, the last thing they need is to hear that their diagnosis might be part of some fashionable trend.
I find it incredibly frustrating that we’re discussing the cost of recognising neurodivergence without giving nearly enough attention to the human cost of failing to recognise it.
Because what about the people who have spent years living with anxiety, depression, low self-esteem or the constant feeling that something about them is different?
What about those who have struggled through education, employment and relationships without ever understanding why?
And what about the people who are finally beginning to find answers, only to be met with suspicion and judgement?
Surely those experiences should matter just as much as the financial cost of providing assessments and support.
We Need More Understanding, Not More Judgement
As a counsellor working with neurodivergent people, and as somebody who is autistic and has ADHD, I believe we need to change the direction of this conversation.
We should be talking about access to assessments, appropriate support, mental health and how we create environments where neurodivergent people can thrive.
We should be listening to people’s experiences rather than immediately questioning their validity.
And perhaps, most importantly, we should remember that behind every statistic, every diagnosis and every headline is a person trying to understand themselves.
Maybe the real question isn’t why so many people are being diagnosed now.
Maybe it’s why so many people went through their lives without being recognised in the first place.
Further Reading: The Current Debate Around ADHD and Autism
The growing public debate about ADHD and autism diagnoses has prompted considerable discussion across the UK media, particularly around overdiagnosis, NHS waiting lists and the funding of assessment services.
Here are a few recent articles and reports that provide context to this conversation. I encourage readers to explore them and consider not only the financial and political arguments, but also the experiences of neurodivergent people whose lives are directly affected.
Further reading:
ITV News — Are too many people being diagnosed with ADHD and autism?
The BMJ — ADHD and autism review: NHS must move away from diagnosis-linked support
The Guardian — NHS bodies impose two-year minimum wait for ADHD and autism assessments
UK Government — Independent Review into Mental Health Conditions, ADHD and Autism
These reports provide background to the debate. The opinions expressed throughout this blog are my own, informed by my professional experience as a counsellor and my lived experience of autism and ADHD.

